Misfortune May Discontinue across Generations

Why do disadvantages persist in some families across generations, while others seem to escape the cycle? A new thesis from Stockholm University, sheds novel light on this question by tracing how socioeconomic and psychosocial disadvantages are associated with mental health problems across three generations. But it also reveals that it is possible to break such a vicious cycle of multigenerational disadvantages for improving mental health of future generations.

Mother and daughter sitting in a sofa discussing lack of money.
Photo: Mostphotos

One of the key findings of the thesis – conducted by Baojing Li at the Department of Public Health Sciences, Stockholm University – is that various forms of misfortune do not exist in isolation, but rather are interconnected, and often times co-occur and are transmitted across generations in complex ways.

For instance, there are interconnected associations between grandparents’ psychiatric disorders and low income of both their children and grandchildren. And transmission of psychiatric disorders from grandfathers to grandsons operates through the fathers’ economic struggles. Moreover, a combination of grandparental socioeconomic and parental psychosocial disadvantages elevates the risk of grandchild psychiatric disorders.

Policies and interventions aimed at enhancing family relationship quality, fostering positive peer relationships, and promoting educational success during childhood, as well as improving psychosocial conditions during adulthood could have far-reaching benefits for the future generations.

However, improved socioeconomic and psychosocial circumstances across previous generations predicts a lower risk of psychiatric disorders in grandchildren.

Baojing Li
Photo: Bildbyrån

“The interconnected nature of socioeconomic and mental health disadvantages and constellations of various dimensions of disadvantages emphasize the importance of integrated and coordinated policy and intervention responses”, Li says. She defended her thesis Misfortune (dis)continues across generations – Multigenerational studies linking socioeconomic and psychosocial disadvantages to psychiatric disorders on June 5 at the Department of Public Health Sciences, Stockholm University.

 

The chain could be broken

The thesis highlights how the parental generation, especially their childhood experiences, matters deeply. For the parental generation, despite exposure to economic hardship from the family of origin, growing up with strong family relationships, good friendships, and solid school performance played a protective role, reducing their own adulthood psychosocial stressors and, by extension, their children’s risk of psychiatric disorders.

Li found that positive changes – like improved childhood experiences or better adulthood psychosocial conditions in the parent generation – significantly lowers the risk of mental health problems in their children. In other words, breaking the chain is possible.

“Policies and interventions aimed at enhancing family relationship quality, fostering positive peer relationships, and promoting educational success during childhood, as well as improving psychosocial conditions during adulthood could have far-reaching benefits for the future generations”, Li says.

Specifically, there is scope for the healthcare sector to provide, for example, intervention programs on parental stress management and more effective treatment of parental psychiatric disorders.

“Social services play a role by providing material support, such as affordable childcare and housing assistance, to relieve economic stressors that can potentially impact parental psychosocial conditions and family relationship dynamics. The school system could facilitate, for instance, preschool and early learning programs that support cognitive and social development, especially for children from disadvantaged family backgrounds”, Li says.

 

Different gender patterns

Her thesis also shows that there are gender differences in this context. Low income was found to be transmitted through the paternal side to grandchildren. Meanwhile, mental illness in grandparents influenced their grandsons’ mental health across both the maternal and paternal lines.

In the association between grandparental socioeconomic disadvantages and grandchildrens psychiatric disorders, the fathers’ friendships and school performance in their own childhood were particularly influential. During childhood, the mothers’ quality of family relationships was shown to have a greater impact.

“The lineage- and gender-sensitive transmission patterns of multigenerational disadvantages point to the need for tailored gender-sensitive public health interventions”, Li says.

 

Interventions should consider social determinants

Taken together, the findings suggest that offspring mental health is shaped by a mix of socioeconomic and psychosocial challenges in previous generations – and that public health strategies aimed at improving mental health of future generations should consider its social determinants in terms of both socioeconomic and psychosocial aspects and adopt a multigenerational perspective.

“These findings highlight strong evidence that what happens in one generation may not continue across generations, and there are potentials for resilience and recovery that may help break this vicious cycle, leading to the discontinuity of multigenerational disadvantages.” Li says. “To truly promote mental health of future generations, we need to think not just in terms of individual treatment, but of socially determined and long-term multigenerational approaches. Empowering one generation creates opportunities for the next. .”

What are you going to do now that you are finished with your PhD?

"I will be joining the statistical consulting company Red Door Analytics to further pursue my interest in advanced statistical models to turn complex data into actionable insights."

How did you end up in Stockholm, Sweden and doing your PhD at the Department of Public Health Sciences, Stockholm University?

"During my bachelor’s studies, I discovered my passion for health inequalities research and statistics. Thanks to the scholarship from Karolinska Institutet, I came to Sweden to pursue a master’s degree. I also worked there as a research assistant thereafter, investigating how educational level relates to mental health using a register-based approach. When the opportunity arose to pursue a PhD at the Department of Public Health Sciences, Stockholm University, it felt like a natural next step for me. My doctoral project builds directly on my earlier work, allowing me to take a multigenerational perspective to understand how inequalities are reproduced over time, while exploring the beauty of a variety of statistical methods."

Håkan Soold

Facts

In her thesis Misfortune (dis)continues across generations – Multigenerational studies linking socioeconomic and psychosocial disadvantages to psychiatric disorders, Baojing Li is drawing on data from the Stockholm Birth Cohort Multigenerational Study. In her research, Li used advanced statistical models to untangle how poverty, family adversities, and psychosocial risks in previous generations contribute to psychiatric disorders among grandchildren, and if early life protective factors reflective of resilience in the parental generation may help break such a vicious cycle of disadvantage transmission. 

The thesis consists of four empirical studies:

Study I demonstrates multigenerational transmission of low income through the patriline (from paternal grandfathers to fathers) to grandchildren, and multigenerational transmission of psychiatric disorders through both the patriline and matriline (from maternal grandmothers to mothers) to grandsons. The patriline-grandson transmission of psychiatric disorders partially operated via low income of the fathers. Additionally, grandparents’ psychiatric disorders influenced their children’s and grandchildren’s income.

Disentangling the multigenerational transmissions of socioeconomic disadvantages and mental health problems by gender and across lineages: Findings from the Stockholm Birth Cohort

Study II provides further insights into multigenerational patterns of disadvantages by showing that combinations of grandparental socioeconomic and parental psychosocial disadvantages elevated the risk of grandchild psychiatric disorders. Importantly, improved socioeconomic and psychosocial circumstances across previous generations predicted lower probabilities of psychiatric disorders among grandchildren. 

Psychiatric disorders following the clustering of family disadvantages in previous generations: a multigenerational cohort study

Study III Grandparental socioeconomic disadvantages and grandchild psychiatric disorders: The mediating role of parental socioeconomic and psychosocial factors establishes the mediating role of psychosocial disadvantages in the parental generation, particularly among mothers, in the association between grandparental socioeconomic disadvantages and grandchild psychiatric disorders.

Study IV Childhood factors in the parental generation and their role in the multigenerational transmission of socioeconomic and psychosocial risks: A cohort study of three generations delves deeper into the mechanisms underlying such multigenerational mediation pattern by identifying parental childhood experiences (i.e., family relationship quality, peer relationship, and educational performance) as important determinants of parental adulthood psychosocial disadvantages and grandchild psychiatric disorders. Parental childhood peer relationship and educational performance mattered more among fathers, whereas family relationship quality played a more important role among mothers.

 

eventNewsArticle

standard-article

false

{
  "dimensions": [
    {
      "id": "department.categorydimension.subject",
      "name": "Global categories",
      "enumerable": true,
      "entities": [],
      "localizations": {}
    },
    {
      "id": "department.categorydimension.tag.Keywords",
      "name": "Keywords",
      "enumerable": false,
      "entities": [],
      "localizations": {}
    },
    {
      "id": "department.categorydimension.tag.Person",
      "name": "Person",
      "enumerable": false,
      "entities": [],
      "localizations": {}
    },
    {
      "id": "department.categorydimension.tag.Tag",
      "name": "Tag",
      "enumerable": false,
      "entities": [],
      "localizations": {}
    },
    {
      "id": "webb2021.categorydimension.Category",
      "name": "News Category (Webb 2021)",
      "enumerable": true,
      "entities": [
        {
          "id": "webb2021.categorydimension.Category.research.news",
          "name": "Research",
          "entities": [],
          "attributes": [],
          "childrenOmitted": false,
          "localizations": {}
        },
        {
          "id": "webb2021.categorydimension.Category.education.news",
          "name": "Education",
          "entities": [],
          "attributes": [],
          "childrenOmitted": false,
          "localizations": {}
        },
        {
          "id": "webb2021.categorydimension.Category.about_us.news",
          "name": "About the university",
          "entities": [],
          "attributes": [],
          "childrenOmitted": false,
          "localizations": {}
        }
      ],
      "localizations": {}
    },
    {
      "id": "webb2021.categorydimension.Label",
      "name": "Etiketter (Webb 2021)",
      "enumerable": true,
      "entities": [],
      "localizations": {}
    },
    {
      "id": "webb2021.categorydimension.Label.en",
      "name": "Labels (Webb 2021)",
      "enumerable": true,
      "entities": [
        {
          "id": "webb2021.categorydimension.Label.en.health",
          "name": "Health and Living Conditions",
          "entities": [],
          "attributes": [],
          "childrenOmitted": false,
          "localizations": {}
        }
      ],
      "localizations": {}
    },
    {
      "id": "webb2021.categorydimension.Keyword",
      "name": "Keywords (Webb 2021)",
      "enumerable": false,
      "entities": [
        {
          "id": "Mental Health",
          "name": "Mental Health",
          "entities": [],
          "attributes": [],
          "childrenOmitted": false,
          "localizations": {}
        },
        {
          "id": "socioeconomic problems",
          "name": "socioeconomic problems",
          "entities": [],
          "attributes": [],
          "childrenOmitted": false,
          "localizations": {}
        },
        {
          "id": "misfortune",
          "name": "misfortune",
          "entities": [],
          "attributes": [],
          "childrenOmitted": false,
          "localizations": {}
        }
      ],
      "localizations": {}
    },
    {
      "id": "Folkhalsovetenskap.eng.lokala.kat",
      "name": "Lokala kategorier Folkhälsovetenskap Eng",
      "enumerable": true,
      "entities": [
        {
          "id": "Folkhalsovetenskap.eng.lokala.kat.nyh",
          "name": "Local news",
          "entities": [
            {
              "id": "Folkhalsovetenskap.eng.lokala.kat.nyh.fo",
              "name": "Research",
              "entities": [],
              "attributes": [],
              "childrenOmitted": false,
              "localizations": {}
            }
          ],
          "attributes": [],
          "childrenOmitted": false,
          "localizations": {}
        },
        {
          "id": "Folkhalsovetenskap.eng.lokala.kat.nyh",
          "name": "Local news",
          "entities": [
            {
              "id": "Folkhalsovetenskap.eng.lokala.kat.nyh.utb",
              "name": "Education",
              "entities": [],
              "attributes": [],
              "childrenOmitted": false,
              "localizations": {}
            }
          ],
          "attributes": [],
          "childrenOmitted": false,
          "localizations": {}
        },
        {
          "id": "Folkhalsovetenskap.eng.lokala.kat.nyh",
          "name": "Local news",
          "entities": [
            {
              "id": "Folkhalsovetenskap.eng.lokala.kat.nyh.om",
              "name": "About the department",
              "entities": [],
              "attributes": [],
              "childrenOmitted": false,
              "localizations": {}
            }
          ],
          "attributes": [],
          "childrenOmitted": false,
          "localizations": {}
        }
      ],
      "localizations": {}
    }
  ]
}